This Best Sandwich Toaster Guide was last updated on September 27, 2021.
Who doesn’t like perfectly toasted sandwiches on a brisk fall day, right? (or to be completely honest, any other time of the year too..)
The key to perfectly toasted sandwiches starts with great ingredients. But that’s not all. To make the ultimate toasties and paninis, you also need a good sandwich toaster or panini press.
Just think of all the delicious sandwiches that await! Sweet, savory, and everything in between!
Here are 11+ of the BEST sandwich toasters money can buy, available on Amazon.
And if you’re not already an Amazon Prime member, you can get a 30-day FREE trial and get access to unlimited 2-day shipping (sometimes even same-day shipping).
That means you could order the sandwich toaster today, and already be eating your perfect sandwich tomorrow.
Criteria for the Best Sandwich Toasters
In evaluating these sandwich makers and panini presses, we looked for these specific criteria that we believe makes for the absolute best sandwich toasters:
- fast heat-up time
- even heat distribution (so your sandwich cooks evenly)
- durable (the appliance is well-built and will last you a while)
- makes crispy bread (but not burnt!)
- consistent cooking
- easy to clean
What Brands Make the Best Sandwich Toaster?
While budget and toastiness preference plays a part here, we believe Cuisinart and Breville are some of the best sandwich toaster brands out there.
Try it for yourself and see what you think!
All-Around Best Sandwich Toaster: Cuisinart 5-in-1 Grill Griddler Panini Maker Bundle with Waffle Attachment
- The 5-in-1 bundle includes the Cuisinart Stainless Steel griddler and a set of two additional waffle plates, which can transform into a contact grill, panini press (sandwich toaster), full grill, full griddle, or half grill/half griddle!
- The hinged floating cover design allows you to adjust the panini press to the thickness of your sandwich, which is perfect to make either bulky toasted subs or a classic PB&J!
- Sturdy construction. The griddler is features a brushed stainless steel housing, which makes it extremely durable.
- The cooking plates are built to drain grease as your food cooks.
- Includes a red light/green light on/off indicator.
- Features dual temperature controls to make sure everything is cooked perfectly.
- The removable cooking plates are nonstick and dishwasher-safe.
- The adjustable top allows the top griddle to lay flat on top of your sandwich instead of at an angle like many other sandwich toasters, which allows for more even toasting.
Best Breakfast Sandwich Maker: Hamilton Beach Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker
Why we love the Hamilton Beach Dual Breakfast Sandwich Maker:
- This breakfast sandwich maker allows you to make custom sandwiches in just 4 steps and 5 minutes! Perfect for a quick, healthy meal to take along.
- You can make 2 sandwiches at at time.
- Includes a FREE breakfast sandwiches recipe book. It includes options for even keto and low-carb dieters!
- All the removable parts on this breakfast maker are dishwasher safe for easy clean-up.
Best Affordable Sandwich Toaster: Hamilton Beach Electric Panini Press Grill
Why we love the Hamilton Beach Electric Panini Press Grill :
- The floating lid of this hot sandwich maker ensures even toasting of any size sandwich.
- Nonstick top and bottom plates.
- The panini press features a built-in ready light that turns green when the press is heated and ready to use.
- For open-faced sandwiches, you can lock the top lid.
- Can be stored upright for easy storage.
Best Toasties-Design Sandwich Toaster: Cuisinart WM-SW2N1 Grill Sandwich Maker
Why we love the Cuisinart WM-SW2N1 Grill Sandwich Maker :
- You can cook 2 sandwiches at a time.
- Features a lid lock to ensure even toasting of the sandwiches.
- The sandwich toaster features both ready-to-cook and ready-to-eat indicator lights/
- Nonstick plates for easy cooking and clean-up.
Best Sandwich Toaster for Large Subs: Chefman Electric Panini Press Grill and Gourmet Sandwich Maker
Why we love the Chefman Electric Panini Press Grill and Gourmet Sandwich Maker :
- This Grill-Panini Press Combo is incredibly versatile. You can use it to toast a large sub, or open the lid to grill burgers, veggies, and more!
- Nonstick grill plates and removable drip tray for easy cooking and clean-up.
- The floating hinge allows the toaster to even press any sized sandwiches.
- Its closed cooking surface (5.5” x 8.75”) gives enough room to toast 2 regular-sized sandwiches at a time.
- Features tilt-up, skid resistant feet for any grease to run drain to the back.
- Incredibly durable and includes a 1-year guarantee.
Best Basic Sandwich Toaster: Brentwood Panini Press and Sandwich Maker
Why we love the Brentwood Panini Press and Sandwich Maker :
- Quick and even heating.
- Non-stick grill plates for easy cooking and cleaning
- Features a power indicator light and a preheat indicator light
- Locking handle for even toasting of your sandwich.
- Easy to carry and takes up minimal storage space.
Best “Toasties” Maker: Auertech Sandwich Toaster and Electric Panini Maker
Why we love the Auertech Sandwich Maker, Toaster and Electric Panini Maker :
- Great for making toasties (and it features a unique “grill marks” design)
- Nonstick plates, for easy cooking and cleaning.
- Features power and preheat indicator lights (red light means the sandwich toaster is on, and green light means it is preheated and ready to cook).
- 800W high-efficiency heating system for the plates to heat up quickly. Crispy sandwiches in 3 minutes!
- Compact design for easy storage (it can be stored upright too!)
- Cool-touch handle and safety lock for portability.
- Features non-slip feet for extra grip and stability.
Best Affordable Sandwich Toaster: Black+Decker 3-in-1 Waffle, Grill & Sandwich Maker
Why we love the Black+Decker 3-in-1 Waffle, Grill & Sandwich Maker :
- The most affordable option for a sandwich toaster
- Features interchangeable plates to turn the sandwich maker into a waffle maker and grill.
- Groove design that allows grease to run down.
- Includes a ready indicator light.
- Plates are nonstick and dishwasher-safe.
Best-Rated “Toasties” Maker: GOTHAM STEEL Sandwich Maker & Toaster
Why we love the GOTHAM STEEL Sandwich Maker & Toaster :
- This sandwich toaster is top-rated on Amazon with over 6,000 reviews!
- Makes four delicious toasties in less than 5 minutes!
- Ultra-nonstick cooking plates that are reinforced with ceramic and titanium for effortless food release (no oil or butter needed!) and easy clean-up.
- Compact design for easy storage (great for dorm rooms!)
- Features an indicator light to let you know when your toasties are done cooking.
- Cool-touch locking handle for extra portability and safety.
- Comes with a 1 year limited warranty
Best Small Multifunctional Sandwich Toaster: Ovente Electric Indoor Sandwich Grill Waffle Maker Set
Why we love the Ovente Electric Indoor Sandwich Grill Waffle Maker Set :
- Interchangeable plates turn this sandwich toaster into a convenient 3-in-1 appliance. Just change the plate and it turns into a waffle maker or a grill!
- Fash heat-up time and quick cooking.
- Featuers an LED indicator light to show when the pwoer is on and plates are preheated.
- Non-stick and removable plates for easy cooking and cleaning.
- Cool-touch handle and skid-free feet for extra safety.
- Handle design and compact size allows for easy portability and storage.
- 1 year warranty.
Why we love the Ovente Electric Indoor Panini Press Grill :
- The 1000-watt heating element toasts your sandwich quickly.
- Plates are adjustable to ensure that your sandwich is pressed evenly and with beautiful grill marks!
- Features an internal thermostat that cycles on and off to keep the set temperature and avoid overcooking.
- Indicator lights that turn on when the grill is powered on and when it is preheated.
- Surprisngly slim design for compact storage.
BONUS: Best Novelty Sandwich Maker: Diablo Stovetop Toasted Sandwich Snack Maker
Why we love the Diablo Stovetop Toasted Sandwich Snack Maker :
- Make your own toasted “Uncrustables” copycat with this stovetop sandwich snack maker!
- The body of the sandwich maker is made out of cast aluminum body with two layers of extra strong coating for non-stick, scratch resistant cooking
- Can be used on gas and electric stovetops
- Heat proof handle
- 100% dishwasher safe
- No plugs or cords for extra safety and portability.
Looking For More Product Reviews & Deals?
- 7+ Must-Have Travel Wallets, According To Reviews
- Crowd Cow Review (2021) with Pictures!
- Good Chop Review: Everything You Need to Know + $100 Off
- 5 BEST Matcha Whisk You Can Buy on Amazon
- Chowbus Review (2021) + $10 Off Coupon
- My Urthbox Review + Get A FREE Box!
- (2021) 10 Best Gift Sets for Women on Amazon
- 12 Best Air Fryers Under $100
- 7 Best Travel Kettles For Your Next Trip
- (2021) 11+ Best Travel Toothbrush for Sparkling Clean Teeth
- Vivoo Review: Everything You Need to Know About the At-Home Wellness Test
- 13+ Best Travel Backpacks for Women
- CAUSEBOX Winter 2021 Review + $10 Coupon!
- 21+ Best Gluten-Free Protein Bars (2021)
- My Organifi Red Juice Review + 15% Off
- (2021) MasterClass Cooking Review: Is The MasterClass Culinary Arts Course Any Good?
- 5 Best Travel Fishing Rod in 2021 – The Ultimate Fan-Favorites!
- Cratejoy Review (2021): 7 Best Cratejoy Subscription Boxes To Try This Month
- My Honest Review of Kencko Instant Smoothies (2020)
- Mighty Fix Subscription Review + 72% Off Coupon
- 13+ Must-Try Wine Subscription Boxes And Best Wine Clubs In 2021
- ButcherBox Review + Unboxing (2021) : Is Butcher Box Worth It?
- 2021 Kencko Review (Updated) : I Tried ALL the Kencko Smoothies Flavors!
- An Honest Review Of Splendid Spoon Meal Subscription
Are there any other brands I need to include in this Best Sandwich Toaster and Panini Press on Amazon guide? Feel free to leave a comment below!
Copyright © All Rights Reserved. Content is written by Michelle Schmidt of dwellbymichelle.com.